Stocks often drop in September — but many investors shouldn’t care

September historically hasn't been kind to banal investors.

Since 1926, U.S. large-cap stocks person mislaid an mean 0.9% successful September, according to information from Morningstar Direct.  

September is the lone period during that astir century-long play successful which investors experienced an mean loss, according to Morningstar. They saw a nett successful each different months.

For example, February saw a affirmative 0.4% return, connected average. While that show is the second-lowest among the 12 months, is inactive eclipses September's by 1.3 percent points. July reigns ultimate with an mean instrumentality of astir 2%.

The monthly weakness besides holds existent erstwhile looking conscionable astatine much caller periods.

For example, the S&P 500 banal scale has mislaid an mean 1.7% successful September since 2000 — the worst monthly show by much than a percent point, according to FactSet.

More from Personal Finance:
Don't expect 'immediate relief' from Fed complaint cut
Americans person much than $32 trillion successful location equity
How a apical superior gains taxation complaint of 28% compares with history

Historically, the past 2 weeks of September are mostly the weakest portion of the month, said Abby Yoder, U.S. equity strategist astatine J.P Morgan Private Bank.

"Starting adjacent week is erstwhile it would [tend to get] get a small spot much negative, successful presumption of seasonality," Yoder said.

Investors holding their wealth successful stocks for the semipermanent shouldn't bail, Yoder said.

Trying to clip the marketplace is almost ever a losing bet, according to fiscal experts. That's due to the fact that it's intolerable to cognize erstwhile bully and atrocious days volition occur.

For example, the 10 champion trading days by percent summation for the S&P 500 implicit the past 3 decades each occurred during recessions, according to a Wells Fargo investigation published earlier this year.

Plus, mean large-cap U.S. banal returns were affirmative successful September for fractional the years since 1926, according to Morningstar. Put different way: They were lone antagonistic fractional of the time.

As an illustration, investors who sold retired of the marketplace successful September 2010 would person foregone a 9% instrumentality that period — the champion monthly performer that year, according to Morningstar.

"It's each conscionable random," said Edward McQuarrie, a prof emeritus astatine Santa Clara University who studies humanities concern returns. "Stocks are volatile."

Similarly, investors shouldn't needfully judge marketplace maxims arsenic truisms, experts said.

For example, the fashionable saying "sell successful May and spell away" would person investors merchantability retired of stocks successful May and bargain backmost successful November. The thinking: November to April is the champion rolling six-month play for stocks.

"History shows this trading mentation has flaws," wrote Fidelity Investments successful April. "More often than not, stocks thin to grounds gains passim the year, connected average. Thus, selling successful May mostly doesn't marque a batch of sense."

Since 2000, the S&P 500 saw gains of 1.1% from May to October, connected average, over the six-month period, according to FactSet. The banal scale gained 4.8% from November to April.

There is simply a humanities crushed wherefore stocks often fared poorly successful September anterior to the aboriginal 1900s, McQuarrie said.

It ties into 19^th period agriculture, banking practices and the scarcity of money, helium said.

At the time, New York City had achieved dominance arsenic a almighty banking hub, particularly aft the Civil War. Deposits flowed to New York from the remainder of the state during the twelvemonth arsenic farmers planted their crops and husbandman purchases accumulated successful section banks, which couldn't enactment the funds to bully usage locally, McQuarrie said.

New York banks would lend funds to banal speculators to gain a instrumentality connected those deposits. In the aboriginal fall, state banks drew down balances in New York to wage farmers for their crops. Speculators had to merchantability their banal arsenic New York banks redeemed the loans, starring banal prices to fall, McQuarrie said.

"The banking strategy was precise different," helium said. "It was systematic, astir yearly and wealth ever got choky successful September."

The rhythm ended successful the aboriginal 20^th period with the creation of the Federal Reserve, the U.S. cardinal bank, McQuarrie said.

September's losing streak is somewhat much baffling successful modern times, experts said.

Investor science is possibly the astir important factor, they said.

"I deliberation there's an constituent of these narratives feeding connected themselves," said Yoder of J.P Morgan. "It's the aforesaid conception arsenic a recession communicative begetting a recession. It gets successful the psyche."

There are apt different contributing elements, she said.

For example, communal funds mostly merchantability banal to fastener successful profits and losses for taxation purposes — alleged "tax nonaccomplishment harvesting" — adjacent the extremity of the fiscal year, typically around Oct. 31. Funds often commencement giving capital-gains taxation estimates to investors successful October.

Mutual funds look to beryllium "pulling forward" those tax-oriented banal income into September much often, Yoder said.

Investor uncertainty astir the result of the U.S. statesmanlike predetermination successful November and adjacent week's Federal Reserve argumentation meeting, during which officials are expected to chopped involvement rates for the archetypal clip since the Covid-19 pandemic began, whitethorn exacerbate weakness this September, Yoder said.

"Markets don't similar uncertainty," she said.

But ultimately, "I don't deliberation anybody has a bully mentation for wherefore the signifier continues, different than the intelligence one," McQuarrie said.