Fact-checking JD Vance’s Attacks on Tim Walz Over a Transgender Sanctuary Law in Minnesota

3 months ago 14

You person a preview presumption of this nonfiction portion we are checking your access. When we person confirmed access, the afloat nonfiction contented volition load.

Fact Check

It was the latest effort by the Trump run to usage Mr. Walz’s grounds connected transgender rights to onslaught him arsenic a far-left liberal.

JD Vance speaking astatine  an event, holding up   his near  manus  portion    helium  holds a microphone with his right.
Senator JD Vance’s remarks astir transgender children earned immoderate of the strongest applause of his quality successful Mesa, Ariz., connected Wednesday.Credit...Ross D. Franklin/Associated Press

Chris Cameron

  • Sept. 5, 2024Updated 3:19 p.m. ET

Senator JD Vance of Ohio connected Wednesday attacked Gov. Tim Walz of Minnesota, his Democratic rival, for a Minnesota instrumentality enshrining rights for transgender children to gender-affirming care, promoting a baseless assertion that the instrumentality allows a authorities to prosecute successful “legalized kidnapping” of transgender children.

It was the latest effort by the Trump run to usage Mr. Walz’s grounds connected transgender rights to onslaught him arsenic a far-left liberal. Mr. Walz has been a salient champion of transgender residents arsenic governor, issuing an enforcement bid and signing authorities that made it easier for transgender patients to person gender-affirming attraction and shielded patients, parents and providers from punishment from different states — a alleged sanctuary law.

Here’s what we know.

What was said

“He signed legislation, helium supported legislation, that would instrumentality children distant from their parents if their parents don’t privation to bash enactment changes.”

“He wants the authorities to bargain your children from you if you don’t hold with Tim Walz’s values. That is not tiny government. That is disgusting, and helium should beryllium ashamed of himself.”
— Mr. Vance said astatine an lawsuit hosted by the blimpish radical Turning Point Action successful Mesa, Ariz.

This is false. Since Mr. Walz was picked arsenic Vice President Kamala Harris’s moving mate, conservative groups, including the Alliance Defending Freedom — the blimpish Christian ineligible advocacy radical — person claimed that the Minnesota authorities authorities tin terminate the parental rights of parents who forestall their children from receiving gender-affirming care. A spokeswoman for Mr. Vance cited the alliance’s arguments to enactment his claim.

But those groups person been incapable to sanction a lawsuit successful which that has happened, pointing alternatively to hypothetical scenarios astir a provision successful the law that grants Minnesota courts “temporary exigency jurisdiction” during custody disputes crossing authorities lines if a kid “has been incapable to get gender-affirming wellness care.”


Thank you for your patience portion we verify access. If you are successful Reader mode delight exit and log into your Times account, or subscribe for each of The Times.


Thank you for your patience portion we verify access.

Already a subscriber? Log in.

Want each of The Times? Subscribe.

Read Entire Article